Sandy Hook, God, and Mike Huckabee

Well, I posted a Facebook statement that has caused a little consternation for a few friends. It said, “The logic of Mike Huckabee: God had a mad man kill a bunch of innocent children and teachers because God is angry that we do not have government sponsored prayer in schools. Perverted and dangerous theology.” I was referring to Huckabee’s weekend remarks on Fox News concerning last Friday’s senseless slaughter of innocents at Sandy Hook School in Newtown, Connecticut. I never suggested that he said those words, but that this summarizes the logic behind what he did say.

My friends challenged me on the basis of a subsequent video Huckabee released explaining what he had meant by his comments. I have listened, but I am not convinced. Since I do not have a camera handy I will have to rely on words to explain what I meant by my post.

My response to my friends is too lengthy for a Facebook reply, so I am offering an extended explanation here. I respect the right each of you has to disagree with me. It is not my intention to offend anyone. Further, this kind of dialogue is dicey because we cannot really hear each other (vocal tones) and we cannot see gestures or body language, etc. Still, I feel compelled to attempt an explanation.

First, I referred to Huckabee’s “logic,” not a specific quote. Perhaps I should have used the word, “inference.” However, I will clarify. What he said was that we shouldn’t be surprised that this happened because we have “systematically removed God from public schools.” That is, in my opinion, code language for “we have taken mandated Christian prayer out of schools.” He used the same “logic” and asserted it more explicitly to account for an earlier shooting at a movie theater in CO when he said, “we’ve ordered God out of our schools and communities; the military and public conversations… we really shouldn’t act so surprised when all hell breaks loose.”

Really? Huckabee’s God can be “ordered” out of our culture? A god so small that his presence or absence depends on legal code is not a god worth our worship. I do not believe God can be so easily dismissed from schools or from the culture, especially by legislative decree.

Others have suggested that God does not go where God is not welcomed. Does that mean that God was not present in the concentration camps of Nazi Germany, even though people such as Bonheoffer were there praying to him? All hell was breaking loose for the Jews and resisting Christians in that situation. I am quite certain that Caesar Domitian did not welcome the God of our Bible in his empire, but I am equally certain that God was present with the martyrs inside the Coliseum. All hell was certainly breaking loose for them.

It is, in my opinion, shallow of Christians to assert, imply, or infer that God can be banned, run off, or expelled from any place, any time, or any situation in this world. Not to mention that some of the same people who say this would be quick to say that God is omnipresent. How can the two positions be reconciled? They cannot be.

This leads me to the crux of the matter. Huckabee was responding to a question from Cavuto, who had asked, “Where was God?” Huckabee decided that God had abandoned post. Huckabee promptly politicized the issue rather than offering a reasonable and thoughtful theological or pastoral response. He answered as a politician, not as a pastor. No thoughtful pastor that I know would tell one of the grieving Newtown parents that their child is dead because we have systematically removed God from our schools. A caring pastor would say something like, “I do not fully understand why God allows this kind of evil to happen, but God loves you and God loved your child. I am sure God is broken hearted by your loss.” I have a feeling Huckabee would have offered a very different answer in private to one of those grieving families than he offered in front of the camera on Fox News.

Thus, I stand by my statement about his logic. As an aside, the media should seek theological clarifications from theologians and pastors, not politicians.

Was God not at Sandy Hook? If he was, was he there to enact vengeance of some sort? Is that sort of God consistent with God as understood in and through the personage and example of Jesus? I think not! If God was not there, then again, what shall we do with the notion of omnipresence?

Perhaps most critical to understand is that Protestant theology rests on the foundational idea that God laid the punishment for our sins on the back of Jesus. We either believe that or we do not. If we believe it, then we cannot believe that God goes around punishing people for sins (either their own or anyone else’s). If we do not believe it, well then, our theology of salvation is in shambles isn’t it?

I agree that a general lack of respect, reverence, and fear for God and God’s teachings has led us through a downward spiral of morality and into a maelstrom of evil. I agree that those who are anti-God have misinterpreted the Constitution when they insist that individual expressions of faith are excluded by the wall of separation between church and state. But I stand firm in resisting the notion that it is the government’s job to fix our morality problem or that our morality problem was caused by the government.

A nation cannot serve God. Only people (individuals) can serve God. And this is where Mr. Huckabee runs off the track – because he can’t decide whether he is a politician or a preacher – by politicizing a moral and spiritual crisis. I will give him a slight break and concede that he did not mean to imply what he implied. His three minute corrective is proof enough that he does not want us to believe he believes what he implied. But…

Huckabee’s attempt to “walk back” his earlier comments was a politically necessary move. But sometimes we just cannot unsay what we have said, and in particular what we infer by what we say.

In conclusion, I stand by my statement. I believe that Mr. Huckabee meant what he said, and I think he said more than he meant to say. It may have been by inference or implication. Nonetheless, it revealed a theological understanding that is, in my opinion, perverted and dangerous.


This entry was posted in Citizenship, Life in general, Theology and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Sandy Hook, God, and Mike Huckabee

  1. Joyce says:

    I hope you know that I respect you … and I appreciate the lengthy explanation about how you feel. I totally ‘get it’. I think your Facebook comment surprised me because first of all, I didn’t hear or read his original comments in the interview… only the rebuttal. And secondly, not being a pastor or theologian I naturally (at least I think it is natural) don’t even understand completely what inferences you heard.

    Just as a personal note on what I think about the subject… if God wants to be in schools … or theaters… or the war zone … or anywhere else… He will be. The problem I see more and more, though, is that He isn’t WELCOME. I’m glad that doesn’t stop Him from being there!

    Love you, my friend! God bless… and Merry Christmas!

    • Ron says:

      Thank you for a kind response. Having good friends is better than having people who just always agree. We sharpen one another. We know God is real; look what he did in your life! Love and best wishes to you and your family for a holy Christmas!

      • Kim Hull says:

        Ron, your friend Joyce recapped my thoughts on this issue precisely. I like Mike and it worried me that we didn’t hear the same thing. Like Joyce said, you are trained perhaps to hear things that we miss. I look forward to reading your FB post, and will continue to. I crave insight from fellow christians that I respect as in you and Mr. Huckabee ( even though he is a politician). It helps me come to my own understanding of God’s word. God uses all of his children in different ways, we can’t all be the same person but we should all have one person in common! And his name is JESUS!
        Thanks for caring enough to respond !

        Love to you and Shirley and all the kiddos

        • Ron says:

          Thanks Kim. I’m glad if this helped. I really do not think a person needs seminary training to figure this out though. Just ask yourself: “What would I tell one of the grieved parents if she were to ask me where God was?” I am certain you would not have given the kind of answer Huckabee gave. I think we can finding better spiritual guides than Mr. Huckabee.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>